I continue to leave book reviews on Goodreads despite its close association with Amazon who are a) clearly evil and will drown the world in a cloying, soul-sucking swamp of globalised, homogenised mediocrity and b) sell my books (see below - buy now - BUY NOW). My most recent is for the first of Philip (that's Sir Philip to you) Pullman's Dark Materials trilogy, or possibly hexalogy given the prequel Book of Dust trilogy. Which probably means he's working on completing a Star Wars-style ennealogy with an additional three sequels. I'm sure his accountant is delighted.
Just in case you think I'm being a tad gauche blogging about a book written half my lifetime ago which is a discovery to nobody whatsoever, I'll humbly point out this is a re-read, albeit one after at least twenty years, and my reviews are as more personal record keeping and less directing a spotlight for the world's benefit. I didn't feel able, in my (five star) review, to add a great deal to the deserved praise heaped on this over the last thirty-plus years, so, instead posed a few ontological questions that sprang to mind which, to a very, very, very small degree, pulled me out of the story.
There's a space on Goodreads for questions and maybe I should have posted these there, but when I checked to see if any of these had been discussed I was surprised by the inanities (favourite: "What pages are the metaphors on?" - thank you Arshdeep, more like Arshshallow) and religious hand-wringing, and minimal kicking of the story's tyres. Readers have had over a decade to pose questions. You'd think they'd have dived a bit deeper.
So here are some from me, from my review, just on the subject of daemons.
Okay, so when young, they can change. They can be big or tiny. So, does that mean matter is being created? They clearly have heft, so they’re not mere illusions. So where does all that additional flesh and blood spring from?
And how do daemons compare to real-world animals? If my daemon turns out to be a hedgehog, is it identical to a non-daemon hedgehog? And, given the taboo of touching others’ daemons (not at all obvious how this came about; there’s no taboo over physical contact between people) could that research ever be undertaken? (And whilst I’m on this question, are there many real world animals? Do people have pets? - there’s a passing reference to them, but nobody seems to have one, so where’s the concept come from in this world.)
What if my daemon turns out to be a rhino or elephant? I'm either housebound or have to live in a garage and am unable to enter most buildings. What if it's an animal specifically suited to extreme environments: xerocole or psychrophile? Do I have to relocate to the poles or desert?
How small is too small? Can my daemon be an ant? A bacteria? Virus?!
There’s a line early on which made me wonder about fate in this world. The Steward's daemon s described thus: "He was a servant, so she was a dog; but a superior servant, so a superior dog." Presumably, his daemon had been a ‘superior dog’ since puberty. So, does that mean he was a ‘superior servant’ from day one? (doubtful); feted to be ‘a superior servant’? (which begs questions about selection for the role and self-fulfilling prophesy); or did it grow to be a superior example of a red setter as he rose in the ranks (counter to the passage’s suggestion that red setters are superior as a breed).
Similarly, are those whose daemons settle as weasels condemned to weasel around for their entire lives?
Lastly, there must be multiple examples and opportunities for inadvertent and accidental human and daemon separation resulting in death. You run for a train, but only one of you makes it. There are two of you to potentially be run over. Isn’t the mortality rate higher in this world? Plus, what if your daemon settles as a mouse and your best friend’s as a hawk? Don’t they act as real animals much of the time? To what degree does the law and pecking order of the jungle apply?
Feel free to answer these questions here. If you go to Goodreads you'll be asked to answer conumdrums such as "How do I read this book?". Echoes of Ethel the Aardvark Goes Quantity Surveying...
#
My Thoughts are with You. Your Thoughts are with the Authorities for Calibration Against Societal Norms
Meet a man mistaken for a robot, a robot which learns the meaning of irony the hard way, a Frankenstein’s monster with a future in tailoring, a talking cat, a talking car, several time travellers, and a host of other characters.
Award-nominated science fiction and slipstream author Robert Bagnall’s second anthology of twenty-four stories, variously bleak, funny, bleakly funny or – very occasionally – optimistic.

2084. The world remains at war.
In the Eurasian desert, twenty-year old Adnan emerges from a coma with memories of a strictly ordered city of steel and glass, and a woman he loved.
The city is the Dome, and the woman... is Adnan's secret to keep.
Adnan learns what the Dome is, and what his role really was within it. He learns why everybody fears the Sickness more than the troopers. And he learns why he is the only one who can stop the war.
Persuaded to re-enter the Dome to implant a virus that will bring the war machine to its knees, the resistance think that Adnan is returning to free the many - but really he wants to free the one.
24 0s & a 2

.jpg)