A confession. But one, I think, I have made before.
I Google myself.
Not often, but I do. Not from narcissism - that's just coincidence - but, being an un-agented writer very much at the bottom of the literary food chain, I have little idea of when I get written about or reviewed.
Would I, for instance, have found that I have my own page on Abebooks.com otherwise? It's not like anyone writes to tell me these things.
Or would I have seen Jim McLeod's Ginger Nuts of Horror review of my story 'Tip of the Tongue' in Slab Press's Screams and Wails?:
Joe is an ageing rock star who wakes in a private hospital after an overdose. His manager chirps about cruise ships. Joe wants only to hear the song he half-remembers from Hamburg, when a woman in a vermilion dress told him the Devil has the best tunes. Bagnall stays in one room and one head, and it is the tightest story in the book. The voice is bitter, funny and hungry. It is also about a man who thinks only death will let him hear the music. The final request sounds small, and it is not.
(Actually, yes I would because Slab Press's impresario Donna Scott passed it on to me. So, err..., some people do write to me to tell me these things. But that's not the point.)
Knowing when you've been written about or reviewed carries a degree of risk, of course. Being, in the eyes of others, a well-meaning amateur, if people don't have anything nice to say they generally don't say anything. Yours is the story not highlighted for praise in the anthology rather than picked out for punishment.
I haven't really been in a position of suffering a vitriolic attack on my prose and have, from time to time, wondered how I would react. Unlike many other performative activities, whether sporting or artistic, writing doesn't offer the workaround of claiming that didn't really come off as I hoped for. The shanked golf drive, the hurdle clipped, a juggling ball dropped. None of those were as intended. But with words, they are as good as you can make it. There is no gap between intention and performance. Which is why a writer feels so naked and vulnerable to criticism. Would I crumble? Would I cry?
Well, I got the hance recently when I stumbled on an almost year-old (I said I don't Google myself often) Goodreads review of The Best of British Science Fiction 2022 which trained its crosshairs on my story 'Sunrunner', describing it as "sub-printable".
I'll say that again. Sub-printable. Thanks, Tomasz.
And my reaction. I laughed. I'm still laughing now. Sub-printable. Wow. It's so unmoored, impossible to pin down to specifics, I'm baffled as to how I'm meant to react. Maybe I should be proud to have been picked out for special treatment, given Tomasz, at time of blogging, has almost 400 books on the go and rates over 200 books each year?
I'm also baffled because, on that same Goodreads page, Eamonn called it "a beautiful story of artistic yearning and science. One of my favourites here," and Maurizio said "un altro racconto molto delicato. 5/5". I'll let you go to Google translate, but let's just say it's the polar opposite of fucking sub-printable.
Which brings me on to my own critical reviews. I try to go down the if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything route, in line with how I was brought up. Which is why, when I'm reviewing the Kindle sci-fi and horror anthologies I get for free, either as samplers or because I'm a contributor, I adopt a fairly standard form of words along the lines of this one I wrote for Horror Library vol 9:
A mixed bag, as these things almost always are. I particularly enjoyed Charles Wilkinson’s tale and Jo Kaplan’s Hugh Howey-esque story. Three and a half stars rounded up to four as ventures like Eric Guignard’s Dark Moon Books deserve our support.
Which is why I'm particularly narked by the actions of some child in Silicon Valley who thinks (s)he has made the world a better place by now allowing fractions of stars on Goodreads reviews. Don't you see what I've done in the review above? None of these anthologies deserve four stars, which would make them better than The Great Gatsby, Catch-22, Brave New World, Fahrenheit 451, Last Exit to Brooklyn, and More Than Human. But I can be glass-half-full by rounding up my rating and hoping it rubs off on their sales. But not any more! If whoever committed this crime is reading this, I hope you're familiar with the term verschlimmbesserung...
The Lucky Ones Will be Replaced by Software
Twenty-four speculative, science-fiction, horror, and otherwise hard to pigeonhole stories.
Includes the novella 'The Credo of Comrade January' and 'Sunrunner', selected for The Best of British Science Fiction 2022 ("An ending that will stay with me for a while" Amazon, "A beautiful story of artistic yearning and science. One of my favourites here" Goodreads).
My Thoughts are with You. Your Thoughts are with the Authorities for Calibration Against Societal Norms
Meet a man mistaken for a robot, a robot which learns the meaning of irony the hard way, a Frankenstein’s monster with a future in tailoring, a talking cat, a talking car, several time travellers, and a host of other characters.
Award-nominated science fiction and slipstream author Robert Bagnall’s second anthology of twenty-four stories, variously bleak, funny, bleakly funny or – very occasionally – optimistic.

2084. The world remains at war.
In the Eurasian desert, twenty-year old Adnan emerges from a coma with memories of a strictly ordered city of steel and glass, and a woman he loved.
The city is the Dome, and the woman... is Adnan's secret to keep.
Adnan learns what the Dome is, and what his role really was within it. He learns why everybody fears the Sickness more than the troopers. And he learns why he is the only one who can stop the war.
Persuaded to re-enter the Dome to implant a virus that will bring the war machine to its knees, the resistance think that Adnan is returning to free the many - but really he wants to free the one.
24 0s & a 2


No comments:
Post a Comment